How does it work?

Peer review and recommendation of research articles

 

Preprints

 

  1. Deposit your manuscript in an open repository, such as bioRxiv, PaleorXiv and PeerJ Preprints. The manuscript must have a DOI and be publicly available (Open Access).

  2. Submit your manuscript to PCI Paleo for peer review. The manuscript must not be under review elsewhere during the evaluation process. Recommenders (editors) of PCI Paleo are alerted of your submission, and if one of them finds it interesting he/she initiates the evaluation process (see point 3). If after 20 days none of them has manifested interest, the manuscript is released and sent back to the authors.

  3. Great! One of the recommenders finds your submission particularly interesting. He/she initiates the evaluation process and seeks the opinion of at least two external reviewers. Recommender and reviewers must declare that they have no conflict of interest of any kind with the content or the authors of the article and that they are not close colleagues, recent co-authors, relatives, or friends of any of the authors. A classic process of peer review follows (reviews, decisions, authors' replies, revisions), and the authors are asked to upload revised versions of their article in the open archive after each revision.

  4. Eventually, the handling recommender decides either to reject or accept (see point 5) the revised article for recommendation.

  5. Congratulations, your article has been accepted for recommendation! The handling recommender writes a recommendation text that is published (with a DOI) on the PCI Paleo website, alongside all of the editorial correspondence (reviews, recommender's decisions, authors' replies). A final version of the peer-reviewed article is uploaded in the open archive with a clear link to the PCI Paleo recommendation and peer review reports. Your work can now be cited as peer-reviewed.

 

Note: Although this is not a mandatory step, authors have the possibility to submit their recommended article, as well as the editorial correspondence and peer review reports, to a regular journal for traditional publishing.

 

 

Recommendation of postprints

Postprints may also be recommended by PCI Paleo if they are of particular interest to the community. In that case, a recommendation text written by a recommender and a co-recommender is published by PCI Paleo, without peer-review.

 

Note: Postprints may include articles already peer-reviewed and recommended by other PCIs, evaluated by other peer review platforms, or published by conventional journals.